Depends on whether or not you have any reason to think the seed could be compromised. The question is about forward secrecy. Do you feel confident that the device will never (until you someday move the funds) be compromised? Maybe a flaw in an MDU or secure element is found some day.
Ledger? Probably a good idea now. Don't trust them. Trezor? Doesn't have a secure element so also probably a good idea. Coldcard and you destroyed the secure elements? Probably fine. Is it one key of a multisig? Also probably fine.
David
npub1mcn…wtll
2023-12-27 00:15:27
in reply to nevent1q…lvhv
Author Public Key
npub1mcneaunh0n9qy54sse0vr06nwhejzghumfjlmu3r54ugwx83qhlshqwtllSeen on
wss://relay.noswhere.comPublished at
2023-12-27 00:15:27Event JSON
{
"id": "f78f63f0527d14b70a29c93e63b5f232236be2591af4a491f85f5429d074588c",
"pubkey": "de279ef2777cca0252b0865ec1bf5375f32122fcda65fdf223a5788718f105ff",
"created_at": 1703632527,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"80e8fde3933a2552b659869cca758fd3ff53cf11959202bf15a4e08a45d2506a",
"",
"root"
],
[
"p",
"ea0c49062a0343e2d581478619acd658664a883c650a6ce6915a7fc0b0328401"
]
],
"content": "Depends on whether or not you have any reason to think the seed could be compromised. The question is about forward secrecy. Do you feel confident that the device will never (until you someday move the funds) be compromised? Maybe a flaw in an MDU or secure element is found some day.\n\nLedger? Probably a good idea now. Don't trust them. Trezor? Doesn't have a secure element so also probably a good idea. Coldcard and you destroyed the secure elements? Probably fine. Is it one key of a multisig? Also probably fine.",
"sig": "d92658e0a35fc36dd61cd27a386719af8b17bc8896517a5a8dfb02e76686440f7d32294bf02dee9de0d3e5f38f0d17633cd545c10511c566e6595d5ed57bebc7"
}