Tony on Nostr: Creatr is really cool, they're doing some unique things to try to paywall and control ...
Creatr is really cool, they're doing some unique things to try to paywall and control the spread of notes to other relays, like putting in an expiration tag.
Unfortunately not all relays obey this and some clients rebroadcast notes anytime they interact with them. So it almost makes it unusable as a paywall.
Really unfortunate. To me, it just confirms that Nostr is only ever usable as a mass broadcast messaging system. Which is okay, but just kills the whole idea of paywalls, "small relays", etc.
Yeah, unfortunately no guarantees on preventing rebroadcasting - just our best effort solution. It is effective on most relay implementations but there is nothing stopping anyone from accepting the notes if they want.
It will be rejected by relays that support expiration or “-“ tags. Resharing of Creatr hosted media is more robust.
Published at
2024-06-15 19:02:23Event JSON
{
"id": "8c1fdc9c5581f08594eb36ed72099bceabdb77de54526c6b985235e3aceb2fc2",
"pubkey": "5be6446aa8a31c11b3b453bf8dafc9b346ff328d1fa11a0fa02a1e6461f6a9b1",
"created_at": 1718470943,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"a29a5c723cf34043742d773f281b50153851ce852cc72436bb23a2a852c5a230",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"p",
"3d842afecd5e293f28b6627933704a3fb8ce153aa91d790ab11f6a752d44a42d",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"q",
"a29a5c723cf34043742d773f281b50153851ce852cc72436bb23a2a852c5a230"
]
],
"content": "Creatr is really cool, they're doing some unique things to try to paywall and control the spread of notes to other relays, like putting in an expiration tag.\n\nUnfortunately not all relays obey this and some clients rebroadcast notes anytime they interact with them. So it almost makes it unusable as a paywall.\n\nReally unfortunate. To me, it just confirms that Nostr is only ever usable as a mass broadcast messaging system. Which is okay, but just kills the whole idea of paywalls, \"small relays\", etc. \n\nnostr:nevent1qqs29xjuwg70xszrwskhw0egrdgp2wz3e6zje3eyx6aj8g4g2tz6yvqpr3mhxue69uhkummnw3ezucnfw33k76twv4ezuum0vd5kzmqzyq7cg2h7e40zj0egke38jvmsfglm3ns4825367g2ky0k5afdgjjz6qcyqqqqqqgzfcksy",
"sig": "69c53519e731cbacc32ec9a4f80379031d27cd9411142e321df02353f96b30891d9bb7a7607ce59a68ca6155ed13edd03da279208f2b13ca7a7ad7903dc66240"
}
