The new bitcoin magazine article you linked comes from a Wasabi developer not a more neutral party like Shinobi. The WabiSabi implementation is fairly new, correct?
If we are using biased opinions, I would like to hear Kortik's counter to these points as he seems to have a deeper technical understanding than I do. Kortik 🇦🇲 (npub15lm…2796)
If I assume all these points are true, they would carry much more weight if they didn't use chain analysis. Really is a huge blow to their credibility and effectiveness of entering their service in the first place.
If they are going to use chain analysis to tell them what is allowed, doesn't this defeat the purpose? What if I received coins from some nefarious actor before going into their mix unbeknownst to me? Will I be rejected and flagged? Runs contrary to the service as that is what you are trying to avoid when trying to mix.
https://sethforprivacy.com/posts/fungibility-graveyard/#wasabi
XMR Future
npub1pc…hv373
2023-03-18 15:40:53
in reply to nevent1q…xd4u
Author Public Key
npub1pcf3fu5upfjwcdnevuw9nk467e24jnsu56aasufrvm36c966je8s2hv373Published at
2023-03-18 15:40:53Event JSON
{
"id": "696853edf5ce50bc378fe37b5e2b885d8f5f8897a4ac243fafa48f3dcbc339fc",
"pubkey": "0e1314f29c0a64ec3679671c59dabaf655594e1ca6bbd8712366e3ac175a964f",
"created_at": 1679150453,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"0578dd2ff9be462ada85f303b03c91998910194f59a57e07afc12c1312fcbf88",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"35f62a33942752d1031eec5ccf756a343cdc9ecb4152a34bbd5fe1f3613ccade",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"4445087cd7c1929340c729c50a446557e522edadbc57b268e8d1694abd33013a"
],
[
"p",
"0b9de7c5e82d26c285690a13cd164149a5a0ee3131b9912e1c0bb36c66b471ab"
],
[
"p",
"0c24e3235228f3ee5369d4a8a46ea92f28f1a83936de61ac6b4003d40344d422"
],
[
"p",
"0e1314f29c0a64ec3679671c59dabaf655594e1ca6bbd8712366e3ac175a964f"
],
[
"p",
"a7f72cd8c8c7cf18fa6f44c131e01d5b88c2f47723a56626ef33d6990e6a9f15",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"t",
"wasabi"
]
],
"content": "The new bitcoin magazine article you linked comes from a Wasabi developer not a more neutral party like Shinobi. The WabiSabi implementation is fairly new, correct? \nIf we are using biased opinions, I would like to hear Kortik's counter to these points as he seems to have a deeper technical understanding than I do. #[6]\n\nIf I assume all these points are true, they would carry much more weight if they didn't use chain analysis. Really is a huge blow to their credibility and effectiveness of entering their service in the first place. \n\nIf they are going to use chain analysis to tell them what is allowed, doesn't this defeat the purpose? What if I received coins from some nefarious actor before going into their mix unbeknownst to me? Will I be rejected and flagged? Runs contrary to the service as that is what you are trying to avoid when trying to mix.\n\nhttps://sethforprivacy.com/posts/fungibility-graveyard/#wasabi",
"sig": "ad29265c407e5a71839861331e7558614a559fb5fad4e973180d3ce613f85cfd56b3d9f95d318f35111250650e4bfc8df1384f4865192a1c5b9568e749ec7e31"
}