https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2023-November/022152.html
Interesting comment by Peter Todd when discussing the possible use of nostr as a new protocol for the bitcoin-dev mailing list. His comments are not particular to that usage though:
"
Strong NACK on nostr. It's a badly designed, centralized, protocol that needs a
significant redesign to be usable. While off topic for this mailing list, some
of its many issues include:
* Reliance on single-key, cryptography that often results in people having
their keys compromised. This is a serious problem in the context of
bitcoin-dev, where faked messages published could easily have market-moving
results.
* Inability to mirror relays: since nostr deliberately ignores the lessons of
blockchains, there is no way to be sure that you have a complete set of
messages from a given person, for a given topic, etc.
* Highly centralized design: since mirroring relays isn't reliable, in reality
nostr operates in a highly centralized fashion, dependent on a tiny number of
relays that can't be easily replaced if taken down.
"
He was replying to this proposal by Ademan (npub19je…pt7r) (I believe).
fiatjaf (npub180c…h6w6) jb55 (npub1xts…kk5s) PABLOF7z (npub1l2v…ajft) Cameri (npub1qqq…n47m) ODELL (npub1qny…95gx)
mambru /
npub12m…h0ysr
2023-11-08 12:59:07
Author Public Key
npub12mdvv7amnzl0mfl58umk0cm0c3l0tj2tl7f276fjy3s24tnnygdqeh0ysrPublished at
2023-11-08 12:59:07Event JSON
{
"id": "94ae7e1c36ad2b42c22a4c1f3bfdcfe47d3fbd1694cf044c6ef1d2d5b09235a2",
"pubkey": "56dac67bbb98befda7f43f3767e36fc47ef5c94bff92af69322460aaae73221a",
"created_at": 1699444747,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"2cb30c36438bad4a2a5107bc98f5cebe6a0229b0554d8cfbd1c99aa3cc7ecec1"
],
[
"p",
"3bf0c63fcb93463407af97a5e5ee64fa883d107ef9e558472c4eb9aaaefa459d"
],
[
"p",
"32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"
],
[
"p",
"fa984bd7dbb282f07e16e7ae87b26a2a7b9b90b7246a44771f0cf5ae58018f52"
],
[
"p",
"00000000827ffaa94bfea288c3dfce4422c794fbb96625b6b31e9049f729d700"
],
[
"p",
"04c915daefee38317fa734444acee390a8269fe5810b2241e5e6dd343dfbecc9"
]
],
"content": "https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2023-November/022152.html\nInteresting comment by Peter Todd when discussing the possible use of nostr as a new protocol for the bitcoin-dev mailing list. His comments are not particular to that usage though:\n\n\"\nStrong NACK on nostr. It's a badly designed, centralized, protocol that needs a\nsignificant redesign to be usable. While off topic for this mailing list, some\nof its many issues include:\n\n* Reliance on single-key, cryptography that often results in people having\n their keys compromised. This is a serious problem in the context of\n bitcoin-dev, where faked messages published could easily have market-moving\n results.\n\n* Inability to mirror relays: since nostr deliberately ignores the lessons of\n blockchains, there is no way to be sure that you have a complete set of\n messages from a given person, for a given topic, etc.\n\n* Highly centralized design: since mirroring relays isn't reliable, in reality\n nostr operates in a highly centralized fashion, dependent on a tiny number of\n relays that can't be easily replaced if taken down.\n\"\nHe was replying to this proposal by nostr:npub19jescdjr3wk552j3q77f3awwhe4qy2ds24xce773exd28nr7emqsm2pt7r (I believe).\n\n\nnostr:npub180cvv07tjdrrgpa0j7j7tmnyl2yr6yr7l8j4s3evf6u64th6gkwsyjh6w6 nostr:npub1xtscya34g58tk0z605fvr788k263gsu6cy9x0mhnm87echrgufzsevkk5s nostr:npub1l2vyh47mk2p0qlsku7hg0vn29faehy9hy34ygaclpn66ukqp3afqutajft nostr:npub1qqqqqqyz0la2jjl752yv8h7wgs3v098mh9nztd4nr6gynaef6uqqt0n47m nostr:npub1qny3tkh0acurzla8x3zy4nhrjz5zd8l9sy9jys09umwng00manysew95gx ",
"sig": "2074c057529806110e43ee445914d3f2c277a4e6475a055adfc97cdaf19d8d1ff2aa5a9a31119f2dd17212782e66528abee86d7a74a2694b0d7f5a18799479e3"
}