Im not sure I understand your argument re cjs, is it that CISA makes batching in general cheaper with cjs being a byproduct, meaning that private txs would have no economic benefit over batched txs and, assuming cjs will continue to be centrally coordinated in a fee model, cj txs continue to be less economically favorable to non-cj txs even with CISA?
If I understand this correctly I agree that CISA doesn't technically address your OP. Practically I think I disagree if we assume that the tx gets cheaper the bigger it gets with full aggregation – reaching sizes of 400+ inputs will likely mostly be unachievable for single signers, so i think cjs practically would have an economic benefit over non-private txs excluding fees (at least until there is non-private CISA collaboration).
Do you have any proposals in mind that would explicitly make privacy cheaper than non-privacy?
L0la L33tz /
npub1mzn…6mak
2024-05-18 02:05:46
in reply to nevent1q…k56h
Author Public Key
npub1mznweuxrjm423au6gjtlaxmhmjthvv69ru72t335ugyxtygkv3as8q6makPublished at
2024-05-18 02:05:46Event JSON
{
"id": "11830b43736e7ff83c65cb000151c5e5984b1d3c0a34ed7b8a327eec9ba4de5b",
"pubkey": "d8a6ecf0c396eaa8f79a4497fe9b77dc977633451f3ca5c634e208659116647b",
"created_at": 1715990746,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"3d4e223dbd9b91e889d945ae13b1984fb22dffde76882574c7d918415c6fd9e2",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"f6fdfc16b47d110eb24f7b0507dbe2d7207f83b33aa80bf5ea63d3eadf505fb1",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"675b84fe75e216ab947c7438ee519ca7775376ddf05dadfba6278bd012e1d728"
]
],
"content": "Im not sure I understand your argument re cjs, is it that CISA makes batching in general cheaper with cjs being a byproduct, meaning that private txs would have no economic benefit over batched txs and, assuming cjs will continue to be centrally coordinated in a fee model, cj txs continue to be less economically favorable to non-cj txs even with CISA? \n\nIf I understand this correctly I agree that CISA doesn't technically address your OP. Practically I think I disagree if we assume that the tx gets cheaper the bigger it gets with full aggregation – reaching sizes of 400+ inputs will likely mostly be unachievable for single signers, so i think cjs practically would have an economic benefit over non-private txs excluding fees (at least until there is non-private CISA collaboration).\n\nDo you have any proposals in mind that would explicitly make privacy cheaper than non-privacy?",
"sig": "6106c704b606a5daae634850b77aae860e3484eaa892eb1c2aa03b697663e1a2ea31c79876b73f718b593ff074f267923771513806433f3035deec5db839f537"
}